Afghanistan, residential area or a Battle Field

I agree with you Maju, no one knows what could happen if the forces leave or stay.
But one thing is for sure if the forces are here there would be unrest in between people and there would be attacks going on, if they leave maybe we see a recap of what happend in 1992-1994 (The Civil War).

It's just a confussed situation, but at the end one thing is for sure that this occupation will end one day as well as others did, But what then ???

Oh man it makes me sick when I think about the future, that's why I say it should be just labeled as a battlefield let everyone in it die and then every invader may enjoy no resistance otherwise till there is one Afghan, there would be resistance, and that's for sure...

I guess the problems of Modern Afghanistan are:

1]Decades of war have left it one of the poorest countries in the whole world.

2]Lack of a stable and powerful central government which makes the complex ethnic mix even more problematic.

3]Lack of a seaport which leads to Afghanistan's dependence on Iran and Pakistan for foreign trade.

4]Afghanistan's strategic position.

Keeping in mind the 'War on Terrorism' is still on and there are vast reserves of Oil and Gas in Central Asia.......Foreign forces arn't going to leave Afghanistan anytime soon.

As far as the future is concerned...it's upto the people of Afghanistan.It all depends on how well different ethnicities are able to come together and form a modern nation from the ruins of an old one.

..........

So how is the relationship between different ethnic groups at govt. level dear Gharanai.Do they still fight over representation in cabinet.I guess there have been some assasination attempts on ministers in central govt. ,are they related to power struggle between different ethnic groups.

What role are the foreign powers playing in developing the infrastructure in Afghanistan.

Thanx for the reply Dear Gharanai.You left my second question unanswered.I would like to know about the progress made in the field of education specially.

I like both Apples and Oranges [how many varieties of citrus fruits do you have in Afghanistan].

Any time dear, there is no problem at all.
Well the process of rebuilding and re-establishment in Afghanistan is going on at a good pace but it's limited to certain areas for example Kabul. As far as education is concerned well, I myself am working as a volunteer with an NGO which is providing basic educational infrastructure and materials to Afghanistan. Well the only thing which has got better since Taleban in real means is the standard of Education and its availability all over the country, the foriegn countries (specially Japan) are really working hard in this field, that's for sure.

Well we do have something around 4-5 types of citrus around, but I bet you will never ever taste a better Apple all around the world than the Apples of Maidan Wardak province. They really taste amazing, along it the Pomegranate (Anaar) of Kandahar Province (one of my favorite) is also populer all over the place...

Any way back to the topic, if there is any other question still, you are most welcome to post it.

Thanx for the reply dear Gharanai.I was interested in progress made in the field of education because I think universal education is the first step in building a modern nation.It is good that Japanese are helping you in this field because Japan made a giant leap to modernity through universal education.All developing nations can learn a lot from the Japanese in this regard.

I would like to know about the developments made in the field of infrastructure for education all over Afghanistan.Like setting up buildings for schools,training new teachers,etc.Is this work being done all over Afghanistan or is it limited to Kabul and other major cities.I think if this work is done all over Afghanistan it would help different ethnicities better understand each other  and unite them in the long run.

It is nice to know that you are working as a volunteer in this field.I know this is a very crucial time for Afghanistan as a whole and you need help from everyone.I wish you success in your venture.In the long run I am very skeptical about the role of NGO's in helping develop a society.My part of world has thousands of NGO's.Those which are really committed don't have the funds and those which are able to attract funds start working like GO's [Government Organisations].I understand you are building from scratch right now so NGO's are welcome.

PS:Thanx for the information regarding Apples and Oranges of Afghanistan.I think Afghanistan is very famous for dry fruits too.Would you like to share some information on dry fruits of Afghanistan.I promise you fruits are very relevant to the development of Afghanistan so talking about fruits doesn't mean that we are deviating from the topic.

Dear Gharanai Western countries always use the "Divide and Rule" formula.It has proved very successful for them over the past few centuries.They are using it in Afghanistan,Iraq,Ex-Yugoslavia,East/North-East Asia and a few other places right now.It won't be a bad idea to have a separate threas on "Divide and Rule" formula.

I know people of Afghanistan are very brave and honest.Strong central leadership is needed in order to unite the people of Afghanistan.How popular is President Karzai in Afghanistan.Is he seen as a true representative of the people or just as an American Puppet.

Apart from bravery and honesty you need education and economic development in order to become a successful Modern Nation.Mongols believe Chingis Khan would be born again.One Mongol member on this forum said Chingis Khan has been born again and he is 5 to 10 years old right now.I hope you get your Chingis Khan soon,who will unite and lead the Afghans in the direction of development and prosperity.

Well it's not that I want any specific information.I know Afghanistan has many varieties of dry-fruits.I just wanted to give a suggestion,  the cultivation of fruits can be commercialised to help economic development of Afghanistan.

My area is very famous for Basmati Rice.It is said that Basmati Rice was introduced in my area by a exiled Afghan Prince/King about 150 years ago.I am sorry I've forgotten the name.Could you please search his name.

PS:I hope you did well in your exam.Information Technology is a very vital sector incase a nation wants to develop rapidly.I know your neighbours don't have much of an IT industry.Whats the view of the current Afghan Govt. regarding development in this field.

Well, he is on average, he is populer in North and Central country but he is know as a puppet by most in South and south-west.
I myself am in his favor taking in point that Afghanistan is developing, My idea is that "it's the modern age and you can't bring down a B-52 fighter with a throw of stone (as we used to do against the British), so in order to get the invaders out of your country first use the resources provided by them, develope yourself and then try to fight them."

That's what my point of view is, so I beleive that Mr. Karzai isn't doing bad as he is trying to stabilize the country and create a central control over the country rather than the control of factions. He is providing a fare balance to the ethnic groups as well which means people could not accuse him for being a Pashtun, so over all I would say he is the kind of guy Afghanistan requires at the moment.

I would reply this line with only one phrase and that is "Very well said!"

 Well, that's interesting, The Reborn Gengis Khan! Interesting claim.
We have examples of our own country, a very good example is King Amanullah Khan Ghazi who got the independece, developed the country and made Afghanistan known by the world, but those westerners couldn't see Afghanistan develope so they ploted a propaganda against him.
I really wish to see a man of his caliber to rule the country, then we may wish for prosperity and real developement.

hmmmm I really don't know his name exactly at the moment but for sure I will try to find his name mean while would you mind telling my the area where you live, I know you live in India but which part.

Well thanks alot for your wishes and hopes. You are right Information Technology is very vital especially for countries trying to develope and Afghanistan too requires it so badly. I could had chosen Politics (my favorite), but then I thaught about what has our politisians done in last 3 decades for our country that I would do so I re-made my mind and choose IT as with it I could really do at least a single service to my Nation.

Well, the Government isn't so keen about this field yet as there are lots of other basic thing to be considered first. Maybe in future few years we get a boom in IT sector.